Which would you choose? Countertops: black vs. white

My Mom and Dad have been working on a major reno project this summer.  Well, actually, they started about a year ago, when they bought their 1980's house in Saskatoon.  They ripped out everything that they could live without, and painted absolutely every surface that was paint-able.  Even the old harvest gold appliances were painted to look like stainless steel!  Ha!

Finally, it is time for the new kitchen!!!  They are going for a look that is classic (but but not too traditional) and elegant (but still stylish).  The cabinets are white shaker style.  But here's the decision to be made... should the counter tops be black or white?  Dad likes black.  Mom likes white.  What do you think?  Here are some inspiration shots...

photo from House and Home

photo from Style at Home

photo from House and Home

photo from House and Home

photo from House & Home

photo from Style at Home